Annual iteration of the series with minimal differences from the previous entry. Improvements are marginal and hard to notice. Only of interest to Xbox-era baseball game collectors.
Complete: box, manual and disc/cart very clean. Lightly handled.
Q1 damagedQ6 completeQ10 new
Compare prices
Loading eBay listings…
Alert active — budget
$
Collector interest
An Acclaim baseball simulation, All-Star Baseball 2004 featuring Derek Jeter offers an American season polished for its time, in the vein of the console's annual sports. Very common in the United States, its collecting interest is low and rests mainly on nostalgia for a specific season rather than scarcity. A very affordable piece, with no notable scarcity.
Is All-Star Baseball 2004 featuring Derek Jeter still worth playing in 2026?
Acclaim's 2003 baseball sim still stands as a worthwhile snapshot of the genre on Xbox. The Skybox engine renders ballparks with real care, animation flows surprisingly well for its age and the franchise mode keeps a lot of depth around scouting, drafting and roster management. Where it shows its years is in the outdated licenses, the looping commentary and the fielding controls that feel stiff next to modern entries. Best enjoyed today by baseball fans curious about the genre's golden age, by Derek Jeter collectors or by anyone digging through forgotten Acclaim sports output.
